Law 25 and AI: can a Quebec firm put client files in a cloud AI?
Law 25 does not ban cloud AI. Before a Quebec firm communicates personal information outside Quebec, the law asks it to do a privacy impact assessment and to make sure the information stays adequately protected. The firm stays responsible for it. An AI server in your own office sends nothing out, so that step does not apply.
We build private AI servers. We are not lawyers, and this is not legal advice. Read the law and the regulator’s guide, linked below, or ask your privacy officer.
What the law asks
- An assessment before data leaves Quebec. Section 17 of the private-sector privacy act asks for a privacy impact assessment before personal information is communicated outside Quebec. It looks at how sensitive the information is, what it will be used for, what protections apply, and the legal rules in the place it goes to.
- A written agreement. The communication must be covered by a written contract that reflects the assessment.
- A named person. Every organization has a person responsible for the protection of personal information, and publishes that person’s title and contact details.
- Penalties. The act provides administrative penalties of up to $10 million or 2% of worldwide turnover, and penal fines of up to $25 million or 4%.
What that means for cloud AI
When a staff member pastes a client’s file into a cloud AI tool, personal information is communicated to that provider. If the provider processes it outside Quebec, the assessment and the contract are expected first. A free consumer account gives you neither.
Business plans with a data agreement can pass that test. It is work, and it has to be redone when the tool or its terms change.
Does hosting in Canada settle it?
Not fully. A United States law, the CLOUD Act, lets US authorities require a US company to hand over data it controls, wherever the data is stored. A Canadian data centre run by a US provider is still within its reach. That is one of the things an assessment has to weigh.
Why a server in the office is simpler
With a private AI server, the model runs on a machine you own. The documents are read there. Nothing is communicated to a provider, inside or outside Quebec, so there is no transfer to assess and no outside party to contract with.
You still have to protect the machine like any other system that holds client files: passwords, access by role, backups.
Questions and answers
- Does Law 25 forbid using ChatGPT at work?
- No. It does not name any tool. It asks for a privacy impact assessment and a written agreement before personal information is communicated outside Quebec, and the firm stays responsible for the information.
- Does Law 25 require data to stay in Quebec?
- No. It allows communication outside Quebec if an assessment shows the information would be adequately protected.
- How does a private AI server help with Law 25?
- The model runs on a machine in the firm’s office, so no personal information is communicated to an outside provider and there is no transfer to assess.